In the Mood for Love: Heart-Shaped Natural Diamond Jewelry Gift Ideas

Meet the latest object of our affection: the heart-shaped diamond.

By |
The Clear Cut | Grace Lee | K Kane

What says “I adore you” more than a heart-shaped diamond? Hearts are an eternal and universal symbol of passion, and love knows no bounds and has been reiterated in jewelry countless times over. Of course, when the motif comes in the form of a sparkling natural diamond, the sweet sentiment is amplified, and there’s even a poetic connection to a specific mascot of love.

“Natural diamonds have been linked to love since their discovery,” shares Grant Mobley, Jewelry and Watch Editor for the Natural Diamond Council. “In ancient mythology, Cupid’s arrows were even tipped in diamonds. Natural diamonds’ link to love led diamond cutters to develop the heart-shaped cut very early in the history of diamond cutting.”

What Is a Heart-Shaped Diamond?

In the Mood for Love: Heart-Shaped Natural Diamond Jewelry Gift Ideas
Lady Gaga attends the Emmy Awards on September 20, 2015 in Los Angeles, California. Taylor Kinney proposed to Lady Gaga that year with a heart-shaped diamond engagement ring designed by Lorraine Schwartz. (Getty Images)

A variation of the brilliant round cut, a heart-cut diamond is revered not only for its symbolism but also because of the precision that is required to achieve symmetry. “The heart-shaped diamond has been around since the 1400s, in the early days of diamond cutting,” Mobley continues. “It is among the most difficult cuts and doing it well requires an expert that specializes in cutting only that shape.” 

When choosing a heart-shaped diamond, look for excellent symmetry—the two halves of the heart should be perfectly balanced and the cleft well-defined. Clarity is important but can be more forgiving than in step-cut shapes like emeralds. Still, aim for a clarity grade of VS2 or higher, as the pointed tip and curved lobes can hide minor inclusions, but larger flaws may still be visible due to the stone’s open facets.

For Valentine’s Day and beyond, heart-shaped natural diamond heart jewelry is the ultimate expression of devotion, whether to yourself or a special someone, and a meaningful way to celebrate love in all forms. Below, see gift ideas from some of our favorite designers.

In the Mood for Love: Heart-Shaped Natural Diamond Jewelry Gift Ideas
Stephanie Gottlieb Prestigious Collection Heart Shape Bypass Ring With Pave Halo, $ 164,795, stephaniegottlieb.com.

Heart-Shaped
Diamond Pendants

In the Mood for Love: Heart-Shaped Natural Diamond Jewelry Gift Ideas
Lizzie Mandler Fluted Button Necklace, $1,240, lizziemandler.com
heart-shaped diamond
K Kane Jewelry Be Still My Heart Pendant, $7,845, k-kane.com
heart shaped natural diamond jewelry valentine's day
Gemella Jewels Diamond Heart Double Bubble Bezel Necklace, $8,900, gemellajewels.com

You simply can’t go wrong with a charming heart-shaped diamond pendant. A welcome addition to any jewelry box, it suits a range of style aesthetics from minimalist to maximalist (amongst her showstopper pieces, Elizabeth Taylor also wore a relatively discreet diamond heart pendant). Whether you prefer a delicate solitaire, one suspended on a chunky chain, or a playful design, it’s a darling way to spread the love to your layers. 


Heart-Shaped
Diamond Rings

heart shaped natural diamond jewelry valentine's day
Robinson Pelham Small Diamond “Eye Love You” Ring, $14,457, robinsonpelham.com
heart shaped natural diamond jewelry valentine's day
Reza La Chose Ring, Inquire for Price, reza.com
In the Mood for Love: Heart-Shaped Natural Diamond Jewelry Gift Ideas
Stephanie Gottlieb Mini Diamond Heart Button Ring , $3,500, stephaniegottlieb.com

Send your dearly beloved a hidden message by way of natural diamonds. At first glance, Robinson Pelham’s gold and diamond ring may look like an artistic rendition of an eternity band, but the mixed cut stones cleverly translate to “Eye Love You.” Designs with multiple hearts, such as Reza’s stunning take on the toi et moi ring (with 9.79ct of brilliant diamonds), can also serve to represent the close bond you share with loved ones.


A Gift For Your BFFs

heart shaped natural diamond jewelry valentine's day
770 Fine Jewelry Fancy Heart Diamond Chain & Silk Cord Bracelets, $605, 770finejewelry.com

Don’t forget about your best galentines! Thank them for always being there for you with a chic friendship bracelet. 770 Fine Jewelry’s mixed chain and silk cord bracelets accented with a bezel-set heart diamond are an everyday wrist accessory they will cherish.


Unique Heart-Shaped
Diamond Jewelry

heart shaped natural diamond jewelry valentine's day
Nina Runsdorf “All That Is” Heart Cut Diamond Pinky Ring, $29,250.00, ninarunsdorf.com
heart shaped natural diamond jewelry valentine's day
Jessica McCormack 0.30ct Heart Shaped Diamond & Blackened Gold Gypset Hoop Earrings, $5,150, jessicamccormack.com

heart shaped natural diamond jewelry valentine's day
Katherine Jetter Diamond Love Necklace, $5,400, katherinejetter.com
heart shaped natural diamond jewelry valentine's day
Grace Lee Heart Column Ring, $12,880, gracelee.com

Hearts aren’t required to be strictly saccharine, either. When cast in modern metal settings and unexpected designs, a heart-shaped stone becomes a sleek and sophisticated way to infuse a little wink into your collection.


Heart-Shaped Colored
Diamond Jewelry

heart shaped natural diamond jewelry valentine's day
Retrouvai 3.07ct Fancy Light Yellow Diamonds Heirloom Bezel Earrings, Inquire for Price, retrouvai.com
In the Mood for Love: Heart-Shaped Natural Diamond Jewelry Gift Ideas
1st Dibs 1.80 Carat Light Fancy Yellow Heart Cut Diamond Ring, $8,980, 1stdibs.com

Dreamy colored natural diamonds are another way to make an impact. Behold the radiant yellow diamond that Retrovai nestles in a notched yellow gold bezel, while The One I Love pairs a chocolate diamond heart with a polished band that echoes the stones’ feminine silhouette.


Heart-Shaped
Diamond Engagement Rings

In the Mood for Love: Heart-Shaped Natural Diamond Jewelry Gift Ideas
Sophie Bill Brahe Coeur Royal Engagement Ring, $37,000, sophiebillbrahe.com
heart shaped natural diamond jewelry valentine's day
Anthony Lent Adorned Hands Diamond Heart Engagement Ring, $19,000, anthonylent.com
heart shaped natural diamond jewelry valentine's day
Ring Concierge Heart-Shaped Eternity Band, $12,348, ringconcierge.com

The unabashedly romantic may gravitate towards the fancy cut for the grandest gesture of them all: the proposal. A heart-cut diamond engagement ring is just as unique as a couple’s love story. Go the classic route and let the heart-shaped center stone shine as a statement-making solitaire, or framed with a halo to declare your love. To dial up the whimsy, opt for a special setting like Anthony Lent’s Adorned Hands or even an eternity band featuring twinkling heart diamonds.

However you choose to wear your natural diamond love token, it’s an endearing reminder that you have captured someone’s heart.


Explore More Heart-Shaped
Natural Diamond Jewelry

Natural Diamond Council (NDC) is a not-for-profit organization dedicated to promoting and protecting the integrity of the natural diamond industry worldwide. NDC serves as the authoritative voice for natural diamonds, inspiring and educating consumers on their real, rare and responsible values.